Costco Kirkland Vs Poppi: Who Makes The Better Prebiotic Soda?

Add The Takeout on Google:

By all accounts, prebiotic sodas have transcended mere trendiness, becoming a legitimate staple of the grocery store soda aisle. As evidence of the drink category's continuous growth, Coca-Cola came for Olipop's throne with a new drink line in February of 2025. When The Takeout tried Coca-Cola's new prebiotic sodas, called Simply Pop, they were solid, but not up to par with Olipop or its closest rival, Poppi. Meanwhile, around that same time, Poppi and Olipop were embroiled in a fierce controversy, albeit one revolving around a marketing tactic and not product quality.

In November of 2026, Costco debuted a proprietary Kirkland Signature-branded prebiotic soda. For what it's worth, it was not Coca Cola's Simply Pop or Olipop that Costco decided to emulate, but Poppi, featuring three direct simulacra of Poppi flavors in its 18-pack. I picked up a box of Kirkland Signature prebiotic soda days after its release, in addition to single cans of the three equivalent Poppi flavors. Ahead are my thoughts on each brand's individual sodas after trying them all, before my pick for whether or not Costco was actually able to best the Poppi prebiotic sodas it's so clearly emulating.

Taste test: Kirkland Signature Prebiotic Soda

The first Kirkland Signature soda I tried was Orange. While some prebiotic sodas can be a little mild in flavor, I was pleasantly surprised by the richness of my Kirkland Orange soda. Most unexpected was a sourness reminiscent of biting into an actual orange, distinct from the milder tartness of sweetened orange juice. I could taste a bit of an Airborne-esque vitamin C element, which I find common in prebiotic orange sodas, but that was really just a net neutral underneath its compelling sour orange flavor.

Costco's Cherry Lime, meanwhile, was a huge letdown. Simply put, I couldn't get past a gross flavor component. The best way I thought to describe it is like that of an unpleasant medicine, not necessarily spoiled, but artificial in a distinctly off-putting way. I could taste both cherry and lime, but they didn't alleviate the bad flavor whatsoever.

Turning things around for Costco, Strawberry Lemon was my favorite soda I tried of the bunch. I got a huge dose of sweet, tart strawberry up front, before lemon took over in its aftertaste. More than combining the flavors of two fruits, I felt the lemon helped deliver on the vitamin C tang characteristic of real strawberries — they're one of 10 foods with more vitamin C than oranges, after all. In their totality, those elements added up to a really tasty soda.

Taste test: Poppi

My Orange Poppi tasted distinctly like Airborne Vitamin C and not much else. When I compared Aldi's Popz prebiotic sodas to Poppi, I made that same observation, finding it lacking in flavor overall. I didn't hate my Orange Poppi by any means, but trying it after the rich Kirkland Signature Orange, its mild, vitamin-esque orange flavor underwhelmed.

Since I found my Kirkland Signature Cherry Lime so off-putting, it didn't take much for Poppi's Cherry Lime to reign supreme. All in all, I didn't find it much better or worse than my Orange Poppi — it tasted like a sweet, vitamin-rich soda first and foremost, with a sort of indistinct fruitiness underneath. Without reading the label I probably wouldn't have been able to identify lime specifically, but I did notice a generally tart element. It was solid.

Finally, Strawberry Lemon was a bit of a surprise, tasting so strongly of lemon, I might have presumed this was a lemon lime soda in a blind taste test. I got some fruit, but it was the same degree of fruit in, say, the fruity Cherry Lime Sprite that came exclusively to Walmarts in January 2026. That was a little unexpected for a flavor that lists Strawberry first. Nevertheless, its lightly fruity lemon-lime flavor was nice, to the extent I thought it was the best of the three Poppi cans I tried.

Final verdict: Costco's Kirkland Signature prebiotic sodas are better than Poppi

I liked two of Costco's Kirkland Signature prebiotic sodas better than the Poppi flavors they copied, but Costco's Cherry Lime obviously complicated things. It was bad, and I don't ever see myself drinking one again. My Poppi sodas, meanwhile, were reliably solid. Nevertheless, Costco's approach is one I respect more, despite resulting in a dud, earning it the distinction of the superior prebiotic soda brand overall.

My Poppi sodas were like Marvel movies, reliably fine, but with virtually zero wow factor. I found my Kirkland Signature sodas weirder, and in the case of both the Orange and the Strawberry Lemon, that weirdness resulted in recipes that pleasantly surprised me. Especially if Costco's Cherry Lime perhaps triggered a flavor sensitivity particular to me, not applicable to the general public, I'd say the Kirkland Signature sodas are quite a bit better than their Poppi equivalents. Even if I wouldn't personally touch one-third of its contents, I would rather pick up Costco's 18-pack and find someone else to take the Cherry Lime cans than stick to Poppi's admittedly kinda boring formula.

How do Costco's and Poppi's prices and nutritional content compare?

At my local Costco, located in the Las Vegas-adjacent Henderson, Nevada, an 18-pack of Kirkland Signature prebiotic sodas costs $14.89. That's equivalent to about 83 cents per soda. Meanwhile, single Poppi cans at the Smiths grocery store closest to my suburban Las Vegas home cost $2.69 each, albeit with the benefit of a buy-two-get-one-free deal at the time of my visit. Since there's no bulk option, three cans for $5.38 — each for about $1.80 — is the lowest price possible.

Nutritionally, each flavor of Kirkland Signature prebiotic soda is 35 calories, with 6 grams of fiber, and 5 grams of sugar. Whereas Strawberry Lemon has 11 grams of carbs, the other two flavors have 12 grams of carbs. Plus, Orange is limited to 3 grams of added sugar, whereas the other two flavors feature 4 grams of added sugar. Meanwhile, each Poppi has 9 grams of carbs, 3 grams of fiber, an 5 grams of sugar. While Cherry Lime is 35 calories, the other two flavors are 30 calories. Finally, just like Kirkland Signature, Orange has just 3 grams of added sugar, whereas the other two flavors have 4. At such low numbers, those differences are effectively all negligible.

How I compared these two products

First, I picked up an 18-pack of Kirkland Signature prebiotic sodas from the Costco warehouse closest to my home in the suburbs of Las Vegas. Then I stopped at a Smiths grocery store between Costco and my house to grab my three equivalent cans of Poppi soda. Since none of them were refrigerated, I stuck three Kirkland Signature cans and each of my Poppis in the freezer for a little over 15 minutes, before letting them sit in my fridge and equalize in temperature for about an hour.

I started my prebiotic soda tasting by trying Kirkland Signature's Orange, noting down my thoughts after a few sips, before switching to Poppi Orange. Once I had thoughts down on the Poppi flavor, I had a few more sips of each to help solidify my initial impressions. I repeated that process for the following two flavors, starting with Costco's sodas before trying their Poppi equivalents. My analyses are base entirely on this experience, and not any past thoughts I may have had on the featured brands or products.

Recommended