10 Heinz Jarred Gravy Flavors, Ranked Worst To Best

Add The Takeout on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

What's a burger without ketchup? What's a hot dog without mustard? What are mashed potatoes without gravy? It's not just the mash either. Gravy enhances meat, biscuits, stews, and several other foods. I even like putting it on vegetables. Now homemade gravy is wonderful, especially if you avoid the 12 mistakes that ruin it. However, it is time consuming to prepare. Fortunately, there are many store-bought brands that are already made for you. Our friends at Heinz make jarred gravies in a variety of flavors.

I sampled 10 different Heinz jarred gravy flavors carefully. I ranked them from worst to best, and present them here with my findings and thoughts. These are, naturally my opinions, but it's a good starting point for your own choosing of a Heinz gravy. Some are meat flavors that you would naturally want to pair with that protein. Others are flavored with garlic, onion, and herbs. I'll let you know how those combine for the taste buds and if they might pair with other foods. Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region. Let's dive in.

10. Herbes de Provence

Originated in the region of France which gives it its name, you may wonder what Herbes de Provence really is. It's a blend of various dried spices common in French cuisine. The exact recipe can vary, but it generally consists of sage, thyme, rosemary, basil, and lavender among others. This aromatic blend can be added to gravy as Heinz had done with this flavor. It makes for a light gravy that is best used on poultry or a vegetable like asparagus.

The gravy has an appetizing light brown color and you can see all of the herbs floating in it. The scent is fresh and herbaceous as it should be and it has a medium consistency, as suits a light gravy. Moving on to taste, I did not like it so much. The gravy had an artificial flavor. I can't pinpoint what it was, but it did not taste like any of the stocks typically used in making gravy.

The flavor of the herb blend was strong and a bit overpowering. It was not a flavor I enjoyed, and together with the gravy, I found it unpleasant. Dipping the bread into it didn't help at all. I imagine the not-so-hot taste would come through no matter how you used it. If you'd like to try it, you can pick up a two pack of 12-ounce jars from Walmart for $16.91. I find that pricey for a store-bought gravy I didn't like, but you may enjoy it.

9. Roasted Garlic & Rosemary

Garlic is aromatic and flavorful and can add so much to many different foods, including gravy. Pairing it with a spice like rosemary could be a dynamic flavor combo. For example, many chefs insist on hitting their lamb with fresh rosemary. With the garlic, it sounds pretty wonderful, but in my opinion, Heinz dropped the ball on this one too. I have to give it some slack because it's mass produced and not homemade, but I didn't love this gravy flavor either.

Like the Herbes de Provence, it has a nice light brown color and medium consistency. You can see plenty of rosemary in the gravy — Heinz did not skimp. The scent of garlic is nicely subtle and your nose will make you very aware of the rosemary. The gravy base has a very light flavor and fades into the background behind the garlic and especially the rosemary, which I found a bit overpowering. Even sopped up with bread, it didn't taste right. The balance of the flavors was off by quite a lot and I would not use this gravy. You can get a 12-ounce jar at Walmart for just $2.92. It's not a big outlay of cash to sample it, but I don't recommend it.

8. Mushroom

I love mushrooms and they are a terrific addition to a gravy. The earthiness adds so much to the foods you ladle the gravy over. I was excited to try Heinz's version of Mushroom Gravy, but ended up disappointed overall. The gravy has a beautiful dark brown color and a nice thick consistency that flows slowly over mashed potatoes. The mushroom pieces are small, but you can see them.

The gravy smelled nice and rich and the mushroom scent was subtle, but strong enough to make it appetizing. Upon tasting it, I did enjoy the overall beef flavor. Nice off a spoon and on the bread as well. It was the mushrooms that let me down. They lacked that earthy flavor you like to taste and they were very chewy — unpleasantly so. I checked the label and found that they were dried mushrooms. I understand this in a store-bought gravy, but the texture was off-putting enough to bump this gravy down toward the bottom of the list. A 12-ounce jar is available at Walmart for under $3. But, my recommendation is to buy one of the higher-ranked Heinz gravies and add your own mushrooms. Use the very best way to saute them first.

7. Chicken

In my book, chicken is a staple gravy because chicken is a staple protein. It's nice to have a tasty batch to ladle over the meat, mashed potatoes, or other vegetables. It's an excellent complement to a Sunday chicken dinner. Heinz did a pretty good job on its Chicken Gravy. The color was spot on with that nice light brown you would expect. There were flecks of what appeared to be pepper. It wasn't too heavy and just enough to enhance the appetizing look overall. This was easily the thickest of all the gravies, and I found it to be a bit too much. The chicken scent was subtle and I really liked it. I was eager to taste it.

In the mouth, the thickness of the gravy was cloying and unpleasant. The flavor was not bad at first, but it left an aftertaste that was artificial. It was better on the bread as the slice neutralized the texture and aftertaste. It wasn't a bad gravy, but I didn't love it. Maybe adding some bullion would help. The price is great at around $1.98 for a 12-ounce jar at Walmart. Not terrible, but not exceptional either, which is why it's at the bottom of the midfield.

6. Brown

Brown gravy is versatile and can be used on all kinds of meats, mashed potatoes, noodles, rice, and to make poutine. Every home cook should have access to a good Brown Gravy. The Heinz brand's version is not bad at all. The color was a perfect shade of brown and made my mouth water just looking at it. The consistency was thick, but not overly so. The scent was wonderful, with a mix of beef and vegetable. I really like a good Brown Gravy and I had to get it into my mouth.

It had a good beef flavor and I picked up a hint of carrot. Vegetables are unsung heroes when it comes to gravy. It was a good complement to the bread and I did enjoy the brown gravy. The reason for its lower ranking is that it was just a bit too rich. It also had the slight artificial aftertaste that many store-bought foods display, which prevented me from ranking it higher. It is worth a try as you may like it more than I did. Walmart has a 12-ounce jar for only around $1.98, so it's not a huge investment. Give it a shot.

5. Caramelized Onion & Thyme

We have reached the upper tier in the rankings and landing midway is Heinz's Caramelized Onion & Thyme Gravy. Thyme adds a nice bit of heat to foods, and caramelized onions are a great complement to burgers, steaks, and other foods. This should be a good one. Visually, it was appetizing with a light brown color showing flecks of thyme. The consistency was pretty much perfect. Nice and thick but not overly so. The gravy had a rich aroma, but I could not detect the onion or thyme in the scent. I eagerly dove into the taste test.

The gravy base had a good rich flavor that I enjoyed. The onion was extremely subtle, and frankly, I felt it could use quite a bit more of that flavor. I thought the thyme was perfect. A bit of spice, but it didn't overpower the gravy. It was good with the bread that soaked it up nicely and the flavors and textures worked well together. Overall, a good gravy, not quite worthy of the top four. I feel it would complement meat nicely, but might be a bit too subtle on mashed potatoes. You can grab a 12-ounce jar from Walmart for a reasonable $2.92.

4. Pork

Pork is another one of those staple proteins and it's nice to have a gravy to match. Although it's not my favorite protein, I do like a pork loin once in a while, so Heinz Pork Gravy was a good one for me to try. It was quite beautiful visually with a medium brown color that suits a pork gravy. The consistency was spot on as well. Perfectly thick for coating your meat and potatoes. The odor was rich and you easily picked up the pork. Definitely whet the appetite.

The flavor was really nice. Full pork taste that was natural. I looked at the label and found it contains pork broth, but also chicken and beef. The combination worked well. Soaked on the bread, it made for a tasty bite and I went back for more. It would be a nice addition to a roast pork sandwich as well or with one of these 14 pork recipes that will solve dinner. A four-pack of the 12-ounce jars costs around $11.68 at Walmart, and it's worth the price. The only reason it didn't make the podium is how good the top three are. Let's get to them.

3. Turkey

What is the center of a Thanksgiving feast for many people? The turkey of course. But it wouldn't be a true feast without all of the side dishes and appetizers, and you have got to have gravy. Now, Heinz does make a Turkey Gravy, another of the staples, and I really liked it a lot. In fact, the only reason it landed in third, is personal taste, and the top two were just that good. Nevertheless, the turkey is a winner. A perfect light brown with the thick but flowing texture that you can pour over your turkey, mashed potatoes, or open sandwich. The gravy had an appetizing turkey scent that made me eager to get to tasting. I was not disappointed.

The turkey flavor spread throughout my mouth and I was pleasantly surprised to find there were bits of ground turkey in the gravy. They were small, and unobtrusive. The bits contributed to the flavor and mouthfeel. Smart move on the part of Heinz. On the bread, the gravy paired nicely, and proved what I suspected about using it on open turkey sandwiches. The Heinz Turkey Gravy was outstanding. You can pick up a 12-ounce jar at Walmart for around $1.98. Trust me, that's an absolute steal.

2. Au Jus

Now, I should mention in full disclosure, that I love au jus. It's no surprise it occupies such a lofty position on our list. Honestly, it finished second by a nose. It was close. The Heinz Au Jus Gravy had the perfect juicy consistency without being too thin or watery. The color was the ideal brown, and made me anticipate the taste. It smelled incredible. Bold and beefy without being overpowering. Surely, the flavor would follow suit. Oh, yes indeed it did.

The label showed beef broth as a main ingredient, and it was there for sure. The beef flavor was bold, but not too heavy, and rich, but not excessively. I could taste hints of various vegetables, and went back in with the spoon a couple of extra times. It was delightful on the bread, and rest assured, at some point, I will use the Heinz Au Jus Gravy with a French dip sandwich. This gravy would also be an excellent covering for mashed potatoes as well as a meatloaf or roast. Walmart has a four pack of the 12-ounce jars for around $11.68 and trust me, it's worth every penny. The Heinz Au Jus Gravy came oh so close to the top spot, but was edged out.

1. Beef

It's time to reveal our winner. Now, beef is my favorite meat. I'm no longer a young man, so for health reasons, I don't eat it as often as I once did. However, I savor the experience every time I do indulge. A tasty gravy furthers the enjoyment of the meat and side dishes. I am happy to report the the Heinz Beef Gravy came out a notch above the Au Jus to top the list. What a gravy it is.

The color is a beautiful dark brown that hints at the flavor within. Texture-wise, it's pretty much flawless. Nice and thick without being cloying. It would flow so well over meat and mashed potatoes. I could also see it being use as a stew gravy. The scent of beef is prominent and set me up for the incredible taste test I was about to experience.

The flavor was big, bold, and on point. The great beef taste that comes from a good roast, steak, or burger. I imagined myself having meatloaf with mashed potatoes, and actually made that for dinner that night. The gravy was delicious on the bread. I would also put this on meat, potatoes, or vegetables. I might even drink it out of the jar. It was that good. That's how it beat out the Au Jus. You can get a 12-ounce jar of this incredible Heinz Beef Gravy from Walmart for only $1.98. At that price, buy two, or even three. I know I will.

Methodology

They say you eat with your eyes first, so I examined each gravy for color and how appetizing it looked. I then dripped it off a spoon to check the consistency. I smelled each one carefully since that sense is so connected to taste. For tasting, I placed a spoonful in my mouth and let it wash over my tongue, taking in the subtleties of each flavor. I was extra thorough when tasting the ones that contained various herbs and other ingredients to make sure I could taste each element and that none was overpowering, throwing off the balance.

Now, if I took the time to prepare a dish using each of the gravies, I wouldn't have had time to compose the words you are reading. I wanted to sample each in a meal-like situation, so I went with bread. Sopping up gravy with a roll is a tradition and is a good way to judge the flavor of the sauces. I rinsed my mouth out with water between gravies to cleanse my palate and create a fresh slate for the next tasting. Go out and choose the gravy you think you'll like best. If you would like to make your own, remember the rule for proper temperature to keep your gravy lump-free. For a hearty breakfast treat, you can try making a super rich three-ingredient sausage gravy in the morning.

Recommended