8 Meats You Should And 4 You Shouldn't Buy From Sam's Club

Add The Takeout on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Like a handful of other chain stores around the country, Sam's Club has developed a following of ardent, avid fans. They rave about their favorite Member's Mark products and they claim that there's no better place to get a good deal. However, not everything at Sam's Club is perfect.

Among frequent shoppers' top complaints? The meat products aren't always up to par. That said, there are still some super-stellar meat deals to be found at Sam's Club, if you know where to look. 

If you're new to your Sam's Club membership, what should you add to your cart and what should you leave on the shelf? We've scoured the reviews and social media to determine which meats you should and shouldn't buy from Sam's Club. Check out our methodology at the end of this article.

Prices below are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.

Buy: Member's Mark USDA Prime Angus beef filet mignon

The Member's Mark USDA Prime Angus beef filet mignon may feel like a splurge, at a current price of $26.98 per pound, but reviewers say that you get what you pay for. These fresh-cut meat come with multiple steaks in a pack, so you're well-equipped to host a double-date night or just treat yourself. On the Sam's Club website, these steaks have earned 4.6 stars out of 5, across more than 4,400 ratings and more than a thousand written reviews, with 80% of raters giving these steaks 5 stars.

So what do the glowing reviews report? Some do mention the high price, but simultaneously note that you shouldn't let that price tag scare you off, as these steaks are worth every penny. In fact, one reviewer said that the steak "leaves you wondering how you would ever settle for anything of less quality." Another reviewer on the website said that, while they don't eat steak all that often, these steaks are turning them into a more frequent steak consumer, as it's the best they've ever had. Complaints are limited and touch on relatively benign issues, such as the multiple steaks being not-so-evenly sized across the pack, and a little too much fat for some.

Don't buy: Member's Mark USDA Prime beef sirloin steak

As you're perusing the steak aisle at Sam's Club, don't accidentally mistake the filet mignon for the sirloin. These are not nearly the same cuts, with filet mignon being leaner and more tender in comparison, as well as more expensive, while the sirloin is often sold in larger portions and is regarded by some as more flavorful due to its fattiness. At Sam's Club, the Member's Mark USDA Prime beef sirloin steaks are sold in packs of four, at a cost of $12.98 per pound — so less than half what you'll pay for the filet mignon. 

Again, though, you get what you pay for. Unfortunately, while the Sam's Club sirloin steaks do have a 4.3-star rating, the steaks only have about 1,650 ratings on the Sam's Club website, and less than 70% of those ratings are 5 stars. Yes, some customers call this steak a "must try" and explain that you don't even need to use a marinade in order to get a tender final product, no matter if you're cooking the steak on the grill or even in the air fryer. However, as you begin scrolling through reviews, you'll find that many customers say the price is too high for what you're getting and the steaks are tougher than expected, not living up to the "prime" expectations.

Buy: Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus beef bone-in cowboy ribeye steak

If you're a tried-and-true carnivore, when you see this steak in your local Sam's Club, you'll probably start licking your chops and planning out your meals for the next couple of days, because this steak could easily feed you for several (or feed a few people for one meal!). The Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus beef bone-in cowboy ribeye is $15.47 per pound, and, while you only get one steak per pack, the Sam's Club website estimates that you'll still currently pay around $45 for this purchase, meaning each steak is about 3 pounds or so.

On the Sam's Club website, this steak has earned 4.7 stars out of more than 1,500 ratings, with 84% of these giving the steak 5 stars. Customers say that these impressive steaks are good for a special occasion, and that they're massive and juicy. However, how you cook them matters. On Facebook, home cooks discussed these steaks, again saying that they were a special occasion item and that the best way to cook them is low and slow, a sentiment repeated in the Sam's Club website reviews, with favorited cooking methods including in the smoker or oven/broiler. Pro tip: Some customers say that you can find these steaks on sale at Sam's Club around the holidays.

Don't buy: Member's Mark Rotisserie Baby Back Ribs

If brands like Sam's Club and Costco are known for one specific type of meat at all, it's the ultraconvenient rotisserie chicken. Considered a loss leader, these birds can go for a mere $5 each, making them a steal for busy home cooks. However, when you're eyeing down that chicken, don't make the mistake of being tempted by the nearby rotisserie ribs. Customers say they are not at all what you want on your dinner table.

You'll get the Member's Mark Rotisserie Baby Back Ribs currently for $18.68 and that price tag is just the start of the problems. On Reddit, posters say that they can easily make better ribs at home without spending nearly $20. Additionally, some describe that, while the ribs certainly smell tasty, the aroma is misleading. They don't come seasoned with any dry rub or barbecue sauce, and one employee even said that they never manage to sell out of the ribs, tossing the leftovers into the trash. Another Reddit review of the ribs called them "absolutely awful" and "leathery and dry."

Buy: Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus beef boneless NY strip steak

We're back to another Member's Mark steak. This time, it's the New York strip, which is typically cheaper than your other options and considered a good value. Flavorful and boneless, New York strips are also relatively beginner-friendly, too, if you're just starting to get to know your way around the grill.

At $13.97 a pound, you'll get four Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus beef boneless NY strip steaks to the package at Sam's Club. On the store's website, the steaks have earned a respectable 4.5 stars — and customers are serious about their ratings for this item, with more than 6,000 of them coming online to state their opinions. Nearly 75% of all reviews are 5 stars, with another 12% coming in at 4 stars.

Reviewers consistently praise these steaks' quality, saying that they're very tender and tasty, with the quality remaining reliable over multiple purchases. A few customers complain about texture, though they are in the minority.

Don't buy: Member's Mark boneless and skinless chicken thighs

Picking up a pack of chicken thighs at the grocery store is a pretty basic task, one wherein you probably assume that nothing will go wrong. Chicken thighs are affordable, flavorful, quick-cooking, and an easy addition to a range of meals. However, if you grab a pack of Member's Mark boneless and skinless chicken thighs, you may just find that this meat falls short.

Individually packaged, antibiotic-free, all-natural, and only $2.86 per pound — these chicken thighs appear, at first glance, to be a great choice, but shopper reviews say otherwise. On the Sam's Club website, this product only earns 4.3-stars out of roughly 1,200 ratings. Many note that it appears Sam's Club swapped out its chicken thigh product and packaging, and the current version is a big downgrade. The thighs are described as smaller, slimy, and filled with water. On Reddit as well, shoppers warn others to "beware the chicken thighs," and advise just going to Aldi instead.

Buy: Member's Mark whole boneless pork loin

Not everyone wants to buy an entire pork loin, as, unless you want to cook the whole thing, you'll have to break it down at home and freeze portions for later. However, even if you've never considered this option before, you may just find that the Member's Mark whole boneless pork loin, at $2.48/lb., is a great deal.

This product knocks it out of the park as far as ratings go, with 4.8 stars across more than 3,500 reviews, with 88% of the ratings giving the pork 5 stars. A mere 1% of the ratings offered up a 1 or 2-star review. 

Reviewers call out the loin's quality, leanness, tenderness, and versatility. On Reddit, Sam's Club members recommend the loin as a must-buy for newbies, saying that they simply grab it and break it down at home into pork chops and a roast, with others noting that the pork loin often is on sale, for an even greater value.

Don't buy: Member's Mark brisket

If you buy a hunk of brisket from Sam's Club, you're going to be in for an investment, with the store's average price for a USDA Choice Angus beef boneless whole brisket coming in at $90.20 — and, unfortunately, some say that this investment is not worth it whatsoever. In a Reddit thread comparing Sam's Club to Costco brisket, many say that Costco is the way to go. Similarly, Grand Champion pitmaster Harry Soo posted a direct comparison between the two products on his YouTube channel and likewise declared the Costco brisket to be superior.

As for the brisket's reviews on the Sam's Club website, they aren't terrible, with the brisket bringing in a 4.4-star rating, but only 68% of reviewers gave this product 5 stars. Common complaints include fattiness and extra gristle that requires a lot of trimming. One reviewer even said that, after they cut all the fat from the brisket, they ended up with a cut of meat that weighed only half what they originally purchased.

Buy: Tyson grilled sweet teriyaki flavored chicken fillets

Not every great find that you come across at Sam's Club will be Member's Mark-branded, as can be seen with this well-reviewed option from Tyson. The Tyson grilled sweet teriyaki flavored chicken fillets are $14.98 for a 3.5-pound bag of frozen chicken thigh fillets and, as far as chicken thighs go, this is a much better option than the aforementioned Member's Mark thighs.

With a 4.5-star average over nearly 8,000 ratings, this is a favorite for quite a lot of Sam's Club members, with many calling the fillets an absolute staple in their households. They're described as extremely versatile, convenient, moist, and flavorful. Try them as is with a few chicken-appropriate sides, pair them with rice or another grain, or add them to a sandwich. 

On Reddit, one customer said that these thighs are "so delicious" that they eventually over-ate them and got tired of them — at which point another commenter chimed in with "may this problem never find me." Across reviews, it seems like one of the preferred ways for cooking these thighs is in the air fryer, upping the convenience factor even further (though some clarify they're not great when cooked in the microwave).

Maybe buy: Member's Mark beef franks

If we're bulk store cafeteria hot dogs, it all comes down to Sam's Club vs. Costco, with some saying that Sam's Club easily wins this hot dog war. Luckily for the fans, they can buy the same Member's Mark beef franks that are served in the store cafeteria, right off the shelf, for $12.96 for a 3-pound package of 12 franks (with larger bulk options available, too).

So why is this a "maybe buy" rather than a "must"? Well, historically, customer reviews for this product have been strong. On the Sam's Club website, they rank a 4.8, with 86% of nearly 5,000 ratings coming in at 5 stars. People love these hot dogs. However, occasionally, someone will pop up and say the dogs have changed or lessened in quality. For instance, earlier in 2026, a Reddit post recorded the change in hot dog ingredients and packaging, resulting in a product that one poster compared to Vienna sausages. This is not a new issue, either. As far back as 2019, folks were complaining on Reddit about hot dog changes at Sam's Club. As such, consider trying them for yourself, but know that you were cautioned.

Buy: Member's Mark rotisserie chicken

Of course, we couldn't put together a list of meats you should and shouldn't buy from Sam's Club without mentioning probably one of the most well-liked meats of all: The Member's Mark rotisserie chicken. As already discussed, this chicken is a loss leader, but it gets people in the door, and once they're inside, they're ready to spend plenty more on other items while they pick up that tasty bird.

Going for $4.98, these chickens have more than a whopping 75,000 ratings on the Sam's Club website, earning a total 4.7 stars, with 83% of all ratings giving the chickens 5 stars (that's more than 63,000 5-star ratings, by the way). Reviewers call it succulent, great, excellent, plump, delicious, and more glowing adjectives. Many mention the chickens' convenience, using it in dishes such as chicken salad and chicken and dumplings. On Facebook, one user asked others in a Sam's Club Fan group about their must-buy meats during a Sam's Club run, and the rotisserie chicken came up time and again. The consensus is clear: You just can't make your own chicken for this price and likely can't expect it to turn out this good.

Buy: Member's Mark boneless center cut pork loin chops

Other Facebook users in the Sam's Club Fans group highlighted the Member's Mark boneless center cut pork loin chops as a must-buy during visits to the store, with one person even saying, "They are thick and so good grilled ... sometimes I think they are better than steak!" That's some high praise, especially considering that the pork chops are much more affordable than many potential Sam's Club steak purchases, at an average price of $9.60 for a pack of six chops ($2.98/lb.).

On the Sam's Club website, the chops get a 4.7-star rating, with nearly 7,000 ratings in total, 82% of those being 5 stars. The chops are lauded for their thickness and minimal fat, and many say that they're a great choice for feeding hungry family members with voracious appetites. Others who may not have quite the same need report successfully freezing the pork chops, separating them into two meals.

Methodology

Items at Sam's Club were delineated as "buy" or "don't buy" based on reviews both on the Sam's Club website and posted across the internet, including on social media platforms, such as Reddit and Facebook. More formal reviews published in past editorial coverage of Sam's Club products were also considered. Prices for all products were taken from the Sam's Club website located in Western Massachusetts. 

Recommended