12 Genius Ways To Use Pumpkin Pie Filling

Add The Takeout on Google:

It's about that time of the year when the same question arises whether you are prepping Thanksgiving dessert or baking for Halloween: What exactly are you supposed to do with that half-empty can of pumpkin pie filling sitting in your refrigerator? Recipes usually call for a cup of pumpkin pie filling, and you are left wondering what to do with the rest. We spoke to a few experts about this conundrum, and they all agreed that if you're only using pumpkin pie filling for ... err ... pie, you're missing out big time. This sweet and spicy filling makes for very interesting recipe swaps, and they kindly agreed to show us how. 

Deden Putra is the executive pastry chef at Pechanga Resort Casino in California. He has been featured in Pastry Art Magazine, Pastry Live, and is the author of the cookbook "Sweet Inspirations." Ricky Webster is a baker, chef, recipe developer, and food writer with more than 25 years of experience, who has taught baking and pastry, owned a bakery, and led monthly cooking demonstrations as resident chef for the Spokane public library. They are joined by Tony Reed, who is the Senior Director of Culinary at Spiceology, a chef-founded flavor brand, where he works with commercial kitchens and home cooks on flavor pairing and shortcut techniques. Here's what all three suggest you use that half-can for before it gets pushed to the back of the fridge.

Coffee cake

Every one of the experts we spoke to were full of out-of-the-box ideas on how to use pumpkin pie filling. Executive Pastry Chef Deden Putra, for example, has a long list that included cheesecakes, crème brûlée, cookies, loaf cakes, and muffins. But, when we ask him to pick one, the answer comes quickly: "My personal favorite is pumpkin coffee cake. The moisture and richness works perfectly in a coffee cake while still being easy to make." A coffee cake also travels well, and Putra promises that, "Bringing this to a party or family event keeps the seasonal flavors while being unique and fun."

The best part? You don't need a brand-new recipe to try this swap. Putra says that dropping the filling into a familiar coffee cake recipe can give it a completely different flavor and make it feel instantly autumnal. Since pumpkin pie filling is usually already sweetened and spiced, just keep an eye on any extra sugar or spices added to the mix. His advice is to taste as you go and adjust. For complementary flavors, he reaches for cinnamon and allspice, plus cranberries and nuts. "I enjoy the contrast between the sweetness of the pumpkin and the tartness of cranberries," he shares. "Nuts also add a nice crunch and texture." His one caution is to keep everything balanced so the pumpkin doesn't take over.

Cookies

Cookies are where pumpkin pie filling feels right at home, and two of our experts are big fans of this hack. For Chef Tony Reed, it started with his childhood. "The first thing that comes to mind when it's pumpkin pie season are these incredibly soft fluffy pumpkin cake cookies with sweet frosting on top my grandma used to make for the family as a kid," he shares. They're still top of Reed's favorites list. For him, the balance of moisture from the pie filling, warm spices, and sweetness is what makes them work. He prefers to top the cookies with a cream cheese frosting because "the slight tanginess cuts through the sweetness." Lately, he has also been baking with brown butter in pumpkin recipes. The nuttiness plays well with the earthiness of the pumpkin. The addition of toasted pecans and orange zest only round things out. 

Chef, baker, and author Ricky Webster also loves to use pumpkin pie filling in cookies and names pumpkin snickerdoodles as a favorite. Webster's advice for any recipe is to taste the cookie dough first, before adding extra sweeteners or spices, and adjust from there. We would add that if you go the snickerdoodle route, go lighter on the sugar in the dough but don't be afraid to still roll the cookies in cinnamon sugar. That crackly coat is the best part. 

Brownies and blondies

If cookies and cakes seem too intimidating, our experts urge you to start experimenting with brownies or blondies instead. These are a low-stress way to explore baking with pumpkin pie filling. Ricky Webster's version is to whip the pie filling with egg and cream cheese (as binding), then swirl it on top of your usual blondie or fudgy brownie recipe. Webster is also upfront about the biggest trap when baking with canned pumpkin. Make sure you know whether you are swapping in a can of pie filling or just regular puree. These are two separate ingredients with different flavor profiles and should be treated as such. Filling is already sweetened and spiced, and treating it like puree gives you an overly sweet dessert. It's an easy mistake to make in the rush of holiday shopping. "I've definitely grabbed the wrong can," Webster admits, so a quick taste before adding any extra sugar or spice is the sensible move.

When it comes to adding pumpkin pie filling to brownies or blondies, a swirl as a thin cheesecake layer sitting on top works best. A blondie base gives you the best view, since the orange stands out against the pale batter. On a brownie, you get a marbled look with the chocolate. Drag a skewer or butter knife through the topping to make the swirl, and don't stir it in, or the pattern disappears. Let the pan cool completely before you cut, and chill it for cleaner squares. Because there's cream cheese in the topping, remember to store leftovers (if any) in the fridge.

Olive oil cake

By now, you may have realized that one of the biggest quirks of using canned pumpkin pie filling is that it arrives already sweetened. That's why Ricky Webster says, "I also like to balance the sweetness by making a pumpkin olive oil cake. The bright, citrusy, grassy notes of a good olive oil help balance the filling's sweetness." To avoid the unidimensional sweetness that a pie filling can otherwise contribute to a cake recipe, it needs something with a bit of backbone. Along with a strong olive oil, Webster also reaches for citrus for the same reason, either lemon juice or orange zest, and says freshly grated nutmeg helps the spices stand out.

Tony Reed is on the same page. He says, "I also love adding citrus zest, in particular orange, to cut through and brighten up the flavor." He offers another rule worth remembering: "Just because it's pumpkin doesn't mean pumpkin spice will make it better." His list of additional complementary ingredients includes toasted nuts, brown butter, salt, and tangy frostings. A fruity extra-virgin olive oil over a very peppery one is preferable so it doesn't fight the spices. And skip a heavy frosting on your pumpkin olive oil cake. A dusting of powdered sugar or a spoonful of plain yogurt is ideal for maintaining a balance of all the flavors at play. 

Ice box cake

Cream-based desserts are where Ricky Webster thinks pumpkin pie filling fits best, such as pumpkin ice cream, mousses, and puddings. One of his favorite ideas takes a Portuguese classic and gives it a fall makeover: "A pumpkin version of the Portuguese icebox cake bolo de bolacha, where layers of Maria biscuits soften overnight between layers of pumpkin-spiced whipped cream until they're almost cake-like."

To recreate this delicious sounding dessert, Webster whips a pint of heavy cream with a little vanilla until it holds stiff peaks, then folds in canned pumpkin pie filling. The amount is up to you: "Fold in enough canned pumpkin pie filling to reach your preferred sweetness and pumpkin flavor," he says. The pumpkin cream then goes between layers of Maria biscuits — thin, dry cookies that are a bit like graham crackers — and the cake does the rest in the fridge overnight. That "to your preferred sweetness" is especially important with a cream-based dessert, since there's no baking step to mellow anything out. Because it needs that overnight rest, this is a make-ahead dessert, which means it's handy for a holiday table. Serve it cold and cut it with a sharp knife.

Tiramisu

A great tiramisu is the perfect balance of sweet, bitter, and creamy, so it's no surprise that Tony Reed recommends it as an unusual use for pumpkin pie filling. Reed elaborates, "Fold a little pumpkin pie filling into mascarpone, layer it with espresso-dipped ladyfingers, and finish with cocoa powder." Reed's general advice for canned filling matters even more with a no-bake dessert. "I always suggest tasting the filling before you start adding anything else," he says. "Different brands have different levels of sweetness and spice." Since nothing gets baked here, what you taste in the bowl is what ends up on the plate.

Reed also shares that a pinch of salt can go a long way in pumpkin recipes. "It really pulls together and balances out all those warm spices and natural sugars," he explains. Here's how I'd handle it in my own kitchen. Ideally, start with small spoons of filling folded into the mascarpone. Keep tasting as you go along and add more pie filling only if needed. Mascarpone is rich, so you want the pumpkin to flavor it without turning it heavy and gloopy. A little orange zest in the cream goes a long way toward lightening the flavors. Give it several hours in the fridge, or overnight, so the layers can set and slice cleanly.

Cheesecake dip

Stuck with a half-empty can of pumpkin pie filling? And strapped for time? This low-effort idea from Tony Reed may just be what you are looking for: "I would whip it in cream cheese and whipped cream with some pumpkin pie spice and serve with graham crackers as a pumpkin 'cheesecake' dip," he describes. That's three ingredients and a box of crackers. Cream cheese is also on Reed's list of favorite pairings for pumpkin pie filling, alongside toasted pecans and orange zest. 

Deden Putra explains why cream cheese works so well with pumpkin. "I like to incorporate cream cheese or sour cream. Both add a nice richness and a little tanginess that helps balance the sweetness of the pumpkin." It's best to let the cream cheese soften on the counter first so it blends smooth with no lumps, then beat in the filling until it's creamy. Whip the cream separately until it holds soft peaks and fold it in gently, so your pumpkin cheesecake dip stays light and fluffy. Chill the dip for half an hour before serving so it firms up. Graham crackers are the obvious pairing but fruit slices and even ginger cookies wouldn't go amiss either.

Oats

Ricky Webster's baked pumpkin steel-cut oats are a good example of how pumpkin pie filling works well for easy breakfast dishes. Webster toasts the steel-cut oats in butter in an oven-safe pot, like a Dutch oven, until "they begin to smell nutty." You could also use a mix of steel-cut and rolled oats. Then half a can of the pie filling goes in with milk and water, and the covered pot finishes in the oven. Because the recipe calls for half a can, it's also a good way to use up an already opened container. Webster's finishing touches are simple and are what makes the dish: "Remove and serve with a dab more butter, a drizzle of maple syrup, and a sprinkling of toasted nuts, dried cranberries, or raisins."

These baked oat leftovers keep well in the fridge for a few days, and all that's needed is a splash of milk to loosen them when you reheat. That makes this a great breakfast to prep and bake on a Sunday and eat through the week.

Pancakes, waffles, and muffins

Breakfast batters are one of the easiest places to use a spoonful of pumpkin pie filling. Tony Reed likes it in pancakes, waffles, muffins, and breads. You can even use pumpkin pie filling for French toast. Deden Putra keeps muffins on his list of favorite uses too, and for a lazy weekend morning, a muffin recipe you already trust is a safe place to start. "You could even spread it over a warm waffle with a little brown butter and toasted pecans," says Reed. "That nutty, toasted flavor brings out a much richer pumpkin." Brown butter is also an easy upgrade for pancakes.

Pumpkin pie batter tends to run thicker and wetter than regular pancake batter, so if it feels a bit too stiff, a splash of milk is all you need to loosen it. Also, watch out for the increased sugar in the recipe as sugar browns fast on a hot griddle. Cook pumpkin pancakes over slightly lower heat than usual, which gives the center time to set before the outside darkens. For muffins, stir only until the flour disappears, and fold the nuts in at the end for a lighter crumb. With a topping like brown butter and a drizzle of maple syrup, you don't need much more. The filling is already doing a lot of the work.

Soup

Deden Putra is a big believer in using pumpkin pie filling in savory dishes like soup. It may be the last place you'd think to use pumpkin, especially the sweetened, spiced variety, but Putra is happy to go there. His method is as speedy as it gets: "Just combine the pumpkin filling with chicken stock and a little water, then season with salt to balance the sweetness. Let everything simmer together until it's smooth and heated through." Putra says the key is balance between the filling and other savory flavors because "you want the pumpkin to complement the dish without taking over."

Putra admits that an unsweetened filling works better if you can get it — or make your own pumpkin puree at home — but adds, "I have made it with sweetened and it works great too." An excellent way to balance the sweetness of pie filling is to start by softening a little onion and garlic in oil. Only adding stock to the filling can taste flat and sautéing the aromatics help liven up the base. A squeeze of lemon or a splash of vinegar at the end brightens the pot, and a pinch of chili flakes gives you something to push back against the sweet. Toasted pumpkin seeds on top add crunch, and blending helps make the soup silky smooth. 

Barbecue sauce and glazes

Pumpkin pie filling in barbecue sauce sounds like a stretch, but Tony Reed has done it more than once. "I've made BBQ sauces and glazes with pumpkin pie filling and used it when barbecuing pork. I love how the deep earthiness of pumpkin pairs with smoked paprika, spicy chiles, tangy mustard, and a splash of apple cider vinegar." Since barbecue sauce is already built on sweet, smoky, and tangy flavors, the filling's sweetness has something to push against. The sauce also gets a thicker body from the pumpkin, which helps it cling to meat when brushed on as a glaze.

Ricky Webster says canned filling can work in savory dishes that already benefit from sweetness, naming barbecue sauce, curry, or a ricotta-based ravioli filling as examples. Ideally, the filling should be swapped in for another single ingredient in a recipe and never as the base for any sauce. Start with a small amount, then build the sauce around it with the smoke, heat, and acid Reed mentions, and taste as you go. Sugar burns quickly over a grill, so make sure to brush the sauce on in the last few minutes of cooking and keep the rest on the side for dipping. Pork is a natural partner, as Reed says. We say roasted chicken would work amazingly well too. 

Butter

If your pie recipe leaves you with with half a can leftover in the fridge, Ricky Webster has a plan for it: "If I have half a can left, I'll cook it down on the stovetop to concentrate the pumpkin flavor and caramelize the sugars." Webster keeps the heat at medium and stirs often until the filling has reduced and darkened. Once it cools, it gets whipped into softened butter, and Webster says the result is "a pumpkin butter that's incredible on scones, muffins, or toast." It's equally good added to buttercream for a pumpkin-flavored frosting.

Cooking the filling down is mostly about patience. Just make sure you use a heavy-bottomed pan and keep the flame on low since the sugars catch easily. Continue to stir and scrape the bottom as it thickens. It's also a nice thing to put on the table with dinner rolls. Keep it covered in the fridge and use it within a few days.

Recommended