12 Popular Chocolate Cereals, Ranked Worst To Best

Add The Takeout on Google:

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Chocolate cereal is a unique beast because it's not just about the cereal itself. Everyone knows that the main event is the freshly flavored milk that's left behind when you're done. Whether you drink the leftover milk with traces of chocolatey flavor or not, it's a cereal flex worth noting.

The ideal life cycle of a chocolate-based cereal is to have a first bite with a major crunch and a last bite that still has some life left before getting soggy. Then there's the question of what counts as a chocolate cereal. Is it a little cookie with tiny chocolate bits? A puff filled with chocolate? A flake with chocolatey pieces throughout? Completely chocolate cereal pieces? Yes to all of it. If it contains chocolate in any way, I consider it a chocolate cereal, which is why the 12 cereals in this ranking offer varying levels and styles of chocolate inclusions.

This list includes everything from marshmallow-studded puffs to unassuming flakes that give cereal milk a brownish hue before you've even gone in for the first spoonful. I sampled each cereal and ranked them so you can decide which will satiate your chocolate craving.

12. Special K Chocolatey Delight

Special K Chocolatey Delight — which will set you back $4.98 at Walmart — is like if you enjoy digging through a bag of trail mix with chocolate to get the parts you want. Crispy flakes against rich chocolate that adds a respectable amount of sweetness — what could possibly go wrong? I'll tell you. It's the ratios. There are far more flakes than chocolate, which leaves you sifting your spoonful to try and manually even it out.

The cereal components are not bad, and I am actually a huge fan of Special K's work. However, you get so many flake-heavy bites because the chocolate kind of sinks to the bottom while it's soaking in milk. I'd rather just eat the original Special K and thoroughly enjoy it rather than hoping for a few morsels of chocolate with every scoop.

The good news about Special K Chocolatey Delight is that the tease of chocolate makes it feel less like dessert for breakfast. The fail is that the rarity of both flakes and chocolate intermingling makes it seem like two totally different bowls of cereal. We know they succeed at solo missions. What we need is for them to work together to build an entirely new identity. While this ranking doesn't discriminate among nuanced levels of chocolate, it still has to play a stronger role than popping in for a cameo every so often. And that's why this one places last.

11. Cookie Crisp

At $4.97 at Walmart, Cookie Crisp presents one of the best sales pitches in the cereal aisle. The pieces even look the part, with chocolate flecks that help them resemble miniature chocolate chip cookies a toddler would serve for tea time in a dollhouse. The cookie shape definitely gives Cookie Crisp a deliciously satisfying visual that makes you want to grab a handful straight from the box and enjoy it as a little cereal appetizer. The first few bites are pleasant, sweet, and crunchy. But from there, it goes a little off the rails for these teeny cookies.

This cereal doesn't have much time in the milk before it gets overly soggy. The shape is persuasive and easily grabs your attention. But once it hits the milk, the chocolate flecks wash away and leave the cookie part to carry the load. Cookie Crisp would get much higher marks if it maintained its crispness so you don't feel like you have to speed eat it to dodge a mushy outcome. It's probably the most fun box of the group, but if you really want to sink your teeth into copious amounts of chocolate, Cookie Crisp probably won't satiate you.

10. Cocoa Loops

Although Froot Loops have an intermittent spot in my pantry, I never even knew that Cocoa Loops existed until this taste test. The ring shape is the champ for this cereal. The hole in the middle keeps them airy, while the rest delivers a satisfying, puffy crunch, regardless of flavor. Kellogg's uses actual cocoa in the cereal, and you can tell as the chocolatey flavor is front and center in every bite. It's definitely a welcome departure from the cereals that make you hunt for the chocolate notes.

Uniformity is great but won't take you to the top among a bevy of chocolate competitors. It becomes monotonous and predictable. After those first few bites, this cereal starts to feel boring. The familiar shape works. However, there is no depth to be found in a bowl of Cocoa Loops. It's like "Groundhog Day" (the movie, not the actual animal predicting the duration of seasons) of cereals. You can pick up Cocoa Loops at Target for $4.49, making them an affordable and acceptable choice for someone who likes routine and wants a very basic chocolate cereal. But for real chocolate lovers, it's just not enough to fulfill a cereal craving.

9. Chocolate Cheerios

Chocolate Cheerios from General Mills are the chocolatey sibling of the original and cost $4.97 at Walmart. There are many ways to hack a bowl of Cheerios, but the signature oat circle in a cocoa form makes sense. It's substantial enough that the chocolate isn't left to do all the work. This cereal has a much more direct and clear identity compared to Cocoa Loops and makes for an easier choice for someone who wants a sweet breakfast without feeling like they are eating a bowl of something that wandered over from an ice cream shop.

In a ranking of chocolate cereals that include many different shapes, textures, and additional components that all effortlessly make chocolate milk, the oats in Chocolate Cheerios demand attention of their own. It's a light spoonful but has the same issue as the Cocoa Loops. Each bite is exactly the same as the one before. It's fine as an everyday breakfast that offers chocolatey notes. If you want more of that chocolate intensity, though, it will leave you looking for a second breakfast (or at least some form of breakfast dessert). If you are loyal to the toasty oat cereal, it's a viable option. If you find yourself lingering in the cereal aisle trying to scratch that chocolate itch, there are better options out there.

8. Oreo Puffs

Oreo Puffs accomplish something that Cookie Crisp cannot. While Cookie Crisp doesn't actually contain any semblance of a cookie, Oreo Puffs do. Each puff contains real Oreo cookie wafers, which allows it to be a dominant part of the cereal, with marshmallows as an enhancement. The marshmallows may not steal the show, but the relationship still brings up some cereal complications. When you bite into an Oreo, the filling is sandwiched between two chocolate wafers, so you get a good amount of both flavors in every bite. The same cannot be said for Oreo Puffs.

Since the marshmallows are free to go their own way once milk gets involved, Oreo Puffs suffer from balance issues. If you are not strategic with your spoon, you risk getting bites full of sugar with no puffs to cut the sweetness. If you like the experience of dunking a cookie in a glass of milk, Oreo Puffs, while hardly one of the more outlandish Oreo innovations, have a stronger hook than Cookie Crisp. If you prefer a more cocoa-forward cereal, regardless of what the name on the box suggests, this is not the cereal for your chocolate cravings — especially at $4.97 a box from Walmart.

7. Frosted Flakes Chocolate Milkshake

Including the word milkshake in a cereal name is a bold move. You're already setting expectations for milkshake flavor, so each bowl had better deliver. A milkshake is a thick, creamy, decadent treat, and, well, the Frosted Flakes version is not. It's not a complete sham, as the chocolate-coated flakes infuse the milk with a good amount of cocoa flavor. The milk in this equation has almost as much responsibility as the cereal to make it successful. The delicate flakes are a nice contrast in texture, but only if you get to them in time — once they soak in the milk, they become extra soggy since they don't have a sturdy frame.

A quick breakfast has its strengths, and this is where Frosted Flakes Milkshake has the potential to shine. If you are the kind of person who multitasks and answers multiple texts and emails between bites, it will not offer the same experience. Priced at $4.98 at Walmart, the chocolate-focused Frosted Flakes are really more for those who place high value on the relationship between the cereal and the milk. The sugar content (12 grams of added sugar per serving) isn't necessarily a shock since it's a hallmark of the original Frosted Flakes, and it earns a spot in the middle for at least staying true to the promise of strong chocolate flavor.

6. Cocoa Puffs

Next up are Cocoa Puffs with a price tag of $4.97 at Walmart. The round cereal puffs are the shining star. There's no peanut butter or marshmallows to distract from their purpose. The puffs are practical and substantial enough to offer a pleasing spoonful every time, and they don't meld together as flakes do. Cocoa Puffs is a cereal you grab when you want a straightforward, no-games, chocolate cereal. It's authentic and direct. That inherent simplicity puts it ahead of the Oreo Puffs and doesn't require you to rearrange each spoonful to construct the best bite.

The issue also lies in its simplicity. Compared to some of the other cereals here, Cocoa Puffs deliver one single note over and over again with zero excitement or nuance. It's an easy pick for a household that agrees on chocolate cereal for breakfast, but can't agree on anything that may come in it. There are other cereals at the same (and lower) price points that offer a little more excitement. Cocoa Puffs earned its spot by nailing the fundamentals, which is no easy feat until you experience the wide range of chocolate cereal offerings.

5. Cinnamon Toast Crunch Mexican Style Hot Chocolate

I did not see this one coming. The best move Cinnamon Toast Crunch made with this iteration was to keep the cinnamon part intact. The wheat and rice squares bring that familiar crunch and flavor combination that stays true to the name. It's also more interesting than cereal that just covers its usual pieces in chocolate. The cinnamon has a very clear and intentional job to warm and add some spice, and it does it well. The square shape provides a bit more substance than the competition with small flakes or pieces.

Since the flavors and pieces are more uniform, you don't have to go on an expedition to find the chocolate. This version of Cinnamon Toast Crunch is $4.97 at Walmart, and you can distinguish every flavor promised on the box. The milk has more appeal here than with others. You're not just getting a bowl of mediocre chocolate milk at the end; the cinnamon adds a unique flavor and really fits the bill as a version of Mexican hot chocolate. Its spot in the ranking is tied specifically to the cinnamon. You have to really like cinnamon to enjoy this cereal because it's a more intense pairing with chocolate.

4. Chocolate Chex

Chocolate Chex achieves a tricky balancing act among chocolate cereals. It's a combination of chocolate and regular Chex squares, but somehow it feels like they belong together instead of eating like two different cereals. The open-grid structure makes for a delightful crunch, with milk interwoven throughout each piece. Whereas the Special K option feels like the chocolate was dropped in as an afterthought, Chocolate Chex offers a contrast that makes the cocoa flavor stand out more. It offers enough chocolate flavor, but the plain squares provide a nice break to break up the sweetness. It's a duo that works and feels purposeful.

This cereal not only works well for breakfast but also makes a tasty snack by the handful. If you are looking for a cereal with wall-to-wall chocolate, the plain pieces will be more of a nuisance to you than a welcome departure. It's a better option for those who like a more restrained but still good chocolate profile. Chex, priced at $3.76 at Walmart, earns its spot because of this balance and the fact that it's easily a cereal you could eat on consecutive mornings without getting bored.

3. Krave

Speaking of dry cereal as a snack, let's discuss Kellogg's Krave. These little pockets of joy consist of a crunchy multigrain shell surrounding a smooth bite of chocolate. They are like tiny little chocolate candy bars in a bowl. Those two textures together are a powerhouse combo before the milk even gets involved. Its biggest strength against competitors is that you never have to fret about how much chocolate versus cereal ends up on your spoon. Each piece is like a self-contained experience where you get both flavors and textures every single time. That's a huge win compared to many of the others.

The downside of Krave is that once the milk makes its way into the outer shell, it quiets the crunch that made the texture so special. It's still delicious, but the bold textures are much better dry out of the box or before the milk makes its way in. If the assignment were to find a cereal you would grab at 10 p.m. for a quick sweet treat, Krave would for sure be a frontrunner. You can pick up a box for $4.98 at Walmart.

2. Reese's Puffs

Reese's Puffs taste like cereal on a mission. I am always down for chocolate and peanut butter in the same place, and this cereal is a solid showing of that dynamic duo. The cocoa shows up with the sweetness, while the peanut butter contributes a roasted, ever-so-slightly salty component. It definitely makes a bowl feel more interesting than just trying to recreate the Reese's candy. The flavors are strong enough that you still taste the essence behind a Reese's peanut butter cup even though you're eating small, crunchy puffs.

It is satisfying to snack on dry, but milk brings out a wonderful creaminess that complements both flavors. Peanut butter is a very dominant flavor and usually capsizes anything it's paired with. That's not a bad thing for Reese's Puffs' taste, but since it does distract from chocolate as the main event, I can't give it the top prize. At $3.29 per box at Target, Reese's Puffs also carves out a spot in the top three based on value alone. It has a full-force flavor profile that makes that price feel like a steal compared to others. If you live in a house divided between chocolate and peanut butter, Reese's Puffs is the perfect solution.

1. Cocoa Pebbles

And the winner of the chocolate cereal extravaganza is Cocoa Pebbles. It tastes exactly like the reason you bought it in the first place. The thin and small pebbles carry a fantastic chocolate flavor with every spoonful. The milk also collects enough cocoa to complement the whole breakfast experience. In a ranking where chocolate is the top priority, Cocoa Pebbles does not rely on a bunch of bells and whistles. It relies on being direct and very chocolate-forward.

Cocoa Pebbles, while small and fragile, can take the lead based on structure alone. The flat shape gives a bowl of Cocoa Pebbles the advantage of giving each bite a slightly different texture and feel. The one obvious drawback is how quickly the pebbles falter under milk. It's another option that doesn't fare well for a leisurely breakfast — but if you are up for a quick breakfast sesh instead, this is the clear winner. The $3.16 price tag at Target makes this the cheapest chocolate cereal on the list, which is pretty amazing if you think about how many stops competitors pull out to justify their higher cost. Cocoa Pebbles get a gold star for giving the chocolate fanatics exactly what they are looking for.

Methodology

I purchased 12 different variations of available chocolate cereals. I honestly had no idea how many chocolate options existed until this very assignment. I tried each cereal out of the box to experience it in its purest form. Looking at taste, texture, and value as criteria, I built the overall ranking. I also tasted each with milk to see how it changed the cereal and whether it affected any of the positions. It was definitely a tight race at times, so I considered the prices and overall value to make some of the calls.

All prices are cited from stores in Boca Raton, Florida, and are subject to change depending on the location. Since the whole point was to rank chocolate cereals, I did my best not to get distracted by extra elements or flavors in certain products.

Recommended