12 Best New Sam's Club Seafood Finds Of 2026 (So Far)

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Seafood is tasty, nutritious, and makes a nice change from beef, pork, and chicken, but it can be kind of pricey. It makes sense, then, to stock up at Sam's Club — after all, Sam's even beats Costco on seafood deals. This year, in fact, many of our favorite new Sam's Club items have ocean origins. We wouldn't want to be shellfish and keep them to ourselves, so we've been sharing our finds as we make them.

Some of this year's fishy finds can be found in the seafood department, while others occupy the frozen food cases. (A surprising number of the best new Sam's Club frozen finds for 2026 were, in fact, seafood items.) The latter is in no way inferior, though, since 'fresh' fish isn't always better than frozen. (Nor is it necessarily all that fresh — at least 70% of the seafood we eat has spent some time in the freezer.) Our selection includes both finned fish and shellfish, with some products being plain and others flavored, breaded, or both. One thing they all have in common, however, is customer satisfaction, since each item has earned a rating of four stars or higher from Sam's shoppers.

Member's Mark Teriyaki Seasoned Salmon Chunks are not only one of our favorite new seafoods at Sam's Club, but they made our list of this year's best new Member's Mark finds. This 4.8-star item consists of chunks of fish marinated in soy sauce, brown sugar, and garlic. One customer described it as "very delicious, seasoned beautifully." The salmon can be stir-fried or baked, then served over rice for a meal that's low effort but high satisfaction.

Purchase Member's Mark Teriyaki Seasoned Salmon Chunks at Sam's Club for $11.54 per pound. (The average package weighs about 1.75 pounds and costs $20.20.)

Gorton's is not only recognized for its Fisherman mascot but also for its frozen fish fillets with high-quality ingredients. Sam's Club shoppers appreciate that Gorton's Classic Crispy Battered Wild Caught Alaskan Pollock Fillets are now available in warehouses, awarding them 4.7 stars. They are easy to cook, have a nice crispy coating that's not too greasy, and the flavor is pretty great, too. Definitely fish and chip-worthy — pass the malt vinegar.

Purchase a 54-ounce, 28-piece bag of Gorton's Classic Crispy Battered Wild-Caught Alaskan Pollock Fillets at Sam's Club for $13.86.

Flounder is usually a pretty mild type of fish, but Hook Line and Savor gives it some pizzazz with a classic bagel seasoning. Sam's Club customers enjoy the crunchy crust and tasty seasoning, rating Hook Line and Savor Everything Crusted Flounder 4.3 stars. According to one, it's " ... absolutely delicious! [...] This is a go-to meal for us several times a month."

Purchase a 27.9-ounce package of Hook Line and Savor Everything Crusted Frozen Flounder at Sam's Club for $15.96.

Salmon is a fish that stands up well to strong flavors, with the Member's Mark Garlic Pesto Salmon Fillet demonstrating that to excellent effect. This salmon fillet is seasoned with dill and has a generous portion of garlic pesto butter. The salmon can be grilled, baked, or broiled in minutes and pairs nicely with either a starch or a salad (or both). It has a 4.9-star rating, and one satisfied shopper called it "delicious to the last bite."

Purchase a Member's Mark Garlic Pesto Salmon Fillet at Sam's Club for $11.87 per pound. (The average package weighs about 3.25 pounds and costs $38.58.)

Scallops are prized for their sweet, non-briny flavor and tender yet chewy texture. They tend to be on the expensive side, however, since they aren't as widely farmed as they are wild-caught. Large sea scallops can cost over $30 per pound, but 4.2-star Member's Mark Wild Caught North Atlantic Sea Scallops offer the same high quality at a much more competitive price.

Purchase a 16-ounce bag of Member's Mark Wild Caught North Atlantic Sea Scallops at Sam's Club for $21.98.

Morey's Marinated Fish Variety Pack is perfect for anyone who wants to eat more seafood but enjoys some variety in their meals. This frozen fish selection comes with blackened tilapia, garlic-herb flounder, and steakhouse-seasoned salmon. This new-to-Sam's item has only been around since August, but it already has a 4.4-star rating with hundreds of glowing reviews. Typical of these was a shopper who enthused, "This marinated fish steaks are really delicious! [...] The sizes are perfect, seasoning on point and ready to cook! [sic] "

Purchase a 30-ounce, 6-piece Morey's Marinated Fish Variety Pack at Sam's Club for $19.47.

Sardines were once the ugly duckling of the canned seafood world, but these days, they're the new darling of proteinmaxxing. Not only are they packed with protein, but they also have more calcium than a glass of milk, along with the lowest mercury levels of any fish. They're also shelf-stable, so a Sam's Club bulk buy of Season Sardines in Extra-Virgin Olive Oil makes perfect sense. Even if you're not a sardine fan yet, this 4.3-star product might change your mind. One Sam's Club member said, "I have been buying sardines for the health benefits, not the taste, until I found these sardines. Good flavor, no fishy aftertaste either."

Purchase six 4.375-ounce cans of Season Sardines in Extra-Virgin Olive Oil at Sam's Club for $10.98.

Is it any wonder poke bowls are so popular? They're like deconstructed sushi, which makes them something anyone can prepare at home with the right fish. The 4.2-star Annasea Yellowfin Tuna Trio Poke Kit, one of our Sam's Club September finds, includes safe, sashimi-grade tuna chunks that simply need to be thawed and mixed with your choice of shoyu, spicy, or wasabi sauces. (The kit contains all three.) Add rice and raw or pickled vegetables to enjoy a delicious, Hawaiian-style meal.

Purchase a 10-ounce Annasea Yellowfin Tuna Trio Poke Kit at Sam's Club for $19.96.

Morey's Marinated Shrimp Variety Pack, which arrived at Sam's Club this summer, also quickly became popular among shoppers. They praise both the quality of the frozen shrimp and the flavor of the sauces, which come in citrus mango, garlic-herb, and teriyaki. "Serve it with a quick rice side dish, salad or vegies for a meal as nice as that found in some fancy restaurants [sic]," suggested one reviewer of this 4.1-star item.

Purchase a 24-ounce Morey's Marinated Shrimp Variety Pack at Sam's Club for $14.47.

As the name implies, Member's Mark Firecracker Shrimp are on the spicy side. They're more sparkler than cherry bomb, though. One reviewer wrote, "Hot but not too hot for me to eat." Each package contains breaded shrimp that can be baked or air-fried, along with a packet of creamy sriracha sauce. "Definitely buying-many more to stock up on. YUMMY [sic]," enthused another fan of this 4-star frozen item.

Purchase a 2-pound package of Member's Mark Breaded Firecracker Shrimp at Sam's Club for $15.94.

Safe Catch Breaded Fish Nuggets may be a little too stubby to be true fish fingers, but their chunky shape makes them kid-friendly. The nutritional aspect, however, will undoubtedly appeal to adults. Not only is the fish sustainably wild-caught pollock, but it's been tested for mercury and fried in avocado oil. Sam's Club shoppers said these fish nuggets also taste great, too. According to one review of this 4.2-star product, "They have a crispy, crunchy coating on the outside while staying tender and flaky inside. The flavor is mild, fresh, and not overly fishy, making them great for both kids and adults."

Purchase a 2-pound box of Safe Catch Breaded Fish Nuggets at Sam's Club for $13.96.

Member's Mark Sweet Harissa Seasoned Salmon goes all in on big, bold flavors with ancho chiles, brown sugar, garlic, and honey. "It's marinated just right; the flavor is perfect; not to sweet [sic]," said one Sam's Club shopper of this 4.9-star salmon. Another declared, "This is best salmon I've had. Very good and I have gotten to the point of always getting it when I go to Sam's. [sic]"

Purchase Member's Mark Sweet Harissa Seasoned Salmon at Sam's Club for $11.48 per pound. (The average package weighs about 1.33 pounds and costs $15.27.)