The 14 Highest-Rated Frozen Pizzas On Amazon

Amazon seems to have cornered the market on nearly every non-perishable item under the sun, but it does have same-day grocery delivery options that allow shoppers to purchase frozen pizzas for door-to-door delivery before they thaw. Prime membership covers delivery costs but non-Prime members can purchase fresh and frozen items via same-day delivery for up to $12.99 per order or have them delivered in three hours or less for $14.99 (the latter option is only available in certain cities).

One thing we love about shopping at Amazon is the user rating system which allows us to see exactly what other shoppers thought about a particular item before we commit to buying it. The frozen pizza selection is a pretty extensive one, so to determine the best ones available we looked for those with the highest number of stars. Since Amazon has such a wide reach, these star ratings didn't come from just a handful of shoppers either. Each pizza on this list has anywhere from dozens to thousands of fans.

We were somewhat surprised to see that nearly all of the top-ranked pizzas are from big name brands, seeing as how Amazon owns so many grocery brands. Only one item on this list is exclusive to the retailer, so perhaps Amazon needs to step up its own frozen pizza game. In the meantime, it offers a decent selection of products from other pizza producers.

One of the highest-rated frozen pizzas at Amazon may come as a surprise. It's Totino's Combination Party Pizza Pack, which has 4.7 stars awarded by nearly 1,500 shoppers. Uncoincidentally, this sausage and pepperoni-topped pizza also provides the biggest bang for your buck, offering more than 2½ pounds of pizza for under $6.00. It's not just the price that keeps people coming back for more, though. One rave review declared, "These are my favorite i buy them all the time." Another asserted, "If I ever had to live on one thing for the rest of my life, it would be Totino's pizza!"

Purchase a 42.8-ounce, 4-count Totino's Combination Party Pizza Pack from Amazon.

Several years ago, The Takeout put DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni right at the top of our ranking of  supermarket frozen pizzas. That flavor is also listed on Amazon, but the Sausage and Pepperoni Rising Crust Pizza makes a more than acceptable substitute judging by its 4.7-star rating. "This is a very good tasting pizza and for the price i would say that you cannot find a better pizza including at my local pizzeria," said one person. According to another, "These rising crust pizzas from Digiorno are the best in rising crust pizzas. The plus is all the meat you get with the cheese."

Purchase a 27.3-ounce DiGiorno Sausage and Pepperoni Rising Crust Pizza from Amazon.

Unlike its namesake fighter pilot (and Snoopy's long-time nemesis), Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza has a 4.6-star rating and many repeat customers. One satisfied shopper called it "one of my favorite frozen pizza." Another was blown away by the low cost: "For the price, this is absolutely unbeatable. incredible value." Our Takeout reviewer enjoyed it too, ranking it third on a list of best store-bought frozen pepperoni pizzas.

Purchase a 20.6-ounce Red Baron Classic Crust Frozen Pepperoni Pizza at Amazon.

Red Baron Deep Dish Singles Pepperoni Pizza also comes in at 4.6 stars, and people praise its flavor, convenient single-serving size, portability, and price. "Generous number of pieces of pepperoni on pizza. Had great taste and was good-sized satisfying serving for one person," was one person's verdict. Another said, "These are my favorite pizza, taste close to homemade."

Purchase an 11.2-ounce two-pack of Red Baron Deep Dish Singles Frozen Pepperoni Pizzas from Amazon.

And a third Red Baron pepperoni product earns 4.6 stars; this one is the Red Baron Brick Oven Crust Pepperoni Pizza. So, what differentiates a brick oven crust from any other kind? Red Baron describes it as "crispy, bubbly, and golden brown" while an Amazon reviewer noted that it's "a bit higher around the edges, and also quite good, easy to chew." Someone else pointed out that the crust isn't the pizza's only asset, declaring, "It taste delicious from the sauce to the cheese you cant go wrong with this [sic]."

Purchase a 17.89-ounce Red Baron Brick Oven Crust Frozen Pepperoni Pizza from Amazon.

Home Run Inn is a Chicago-area restaurant chain that claims to have invented Chicago's unique tavern-style pizza back in the 1940s and now markets it in frozen form. Its Classic Cheese Pizza has a 4.6-star rating on Amazon, with one self-professed pizza snob saying, "Absolutely the only frozen pizza we will eat. Delicious! Consistently great quality and not super expensive."

Purchase a 27-ounce Home Run Inn Classic Cheese Pizza from Amazon.

The single-serve version of the Home Run Inn Classic Cheese Pizza also has a 4.6-star rating and is an exact dupe of the above pizza only in miniature. "Its like ordering fresh, inexpensive take out," said one reviewer. Someone else agreed, saying, "Tastes just like the restaurant. You wouldn't even know it was frozen pizza."

Purchase a 7.5-ounce Home Run Inn Single Serve Cheese Pizza from Amazon.

And the Home Run Inn scores a triple with yet another top-rated pizza, the 4.6-star Ultra Thin Sausage Pizza. This one has a cracker-like crust that's perfect for anyone who wants their pizza to be practically all sauce, cheese, and topping with just the bare minimum base to hold it. Many customers call it a favorite, with one fan saying, "It's just as good as my favorite pizza place I order from."

Purchase a 20.75-ounce Home Run Inn Ultra Thin Sausage Pizza from Amazon.

Amy's Margherita Pizza is one of the pricier options on the list, but it markets itself as an upscale choice by touting organic tomatoes and basil on a hand-stretched crust. Thousands of reviewers seem to feel this pizza is worth the price as it has a 4.5 rating overall. According to one person who gave it a full five stars, "It looks healthy and it tastes healthy and it has great ingredients and it's delicious! And might I add the crust is to die for!"

Purchase a 13-ounce Amy's Margherita Pizza from Amazon.

While there are a few other brands offering frozen stuffed crust pizzas, DiGiorno is the undisputed king of this market sector. Its Four Cheese Stuffed Crust Personal Size Pizza is an absolute hit with Amazon shoppers, who have given it 4.5 stars. "Great taste, thick pizza, soft very cheesy crust, personal-size convenience," said one. Another enthused, "I love the taste, the texture, the size, the value ... everything about these pizzas!"

Purchase an 8.5-ounce DiGiorno Four Cheese Stuffed Crust Personal Size Pizza from Amazon.

California Pizza Kitchen's Sicilian Recipe Crispy Thin Crust Pizza may be the most gourmet offering on this list with its three-meat combo of ham, sausage, and salami joined with basil, marinara sauce, and a fontina-mozzarella cheese blend. Yes, it's a little pricier than some offerings, but judging by the 4.4-star rating plenty of people are willing to pay the upcharge. "Based on frozen pizzas this was best and definitely worth the extra cash!" affirmed one review. A second shopper concurred, "It's a more expensive pizza but deservedly so. If flavor and texture matter, and they do to me, this pie is totally worthwhile."

Purchase a 15.5-ounce California Pizza Kitchen Sicilian Recipe Crispy Thin Crust Pizza at Amazon.

If you want a single-serving pizza that's ready in a minute or two, then Lean Cuisine Signature Pepperoni Pizza is a great pick. For a microwaveable pizza, it exceeds expectations, as attested by its 4.4-star rating. "Some microwave pizzas are not very good. We all know that. This one actually is. If you are going to put a pizza in the microwave and not the oven, I would go with this one," explained one reviewer. Another felt that the pizza was tasty as well as convenient, saying, "I personally love the pizza! Personal size that keeps me ... satisfied."

Purchase a 6-ounce Lean Cuisine Signature Pepperoni Pizza from Amazon.

Screamin' Sicilian pizzas are known for humorous names and generous toppings, and the Mother of Meat! is no exception. One Amazon customer described it as "a carnivore's dream, packing a punch with spicy Italian sausage, premium pepperoni, julienne ham, and smoky bacon." Someone else enthused, "This was the best frozen pizza I've ever eaten! Perfect crust that was easy to eat. Abundant toppings and the sauce was not overpowering." A third person noted, "We always have to add our toppings to others, but no need with these!"

Purchase a 23.4-ounce Screamin' Sicilian Pizza Co. Mother of Meat! pizza from Amazon.

The highest-rated Amazon-branded frozen pizza currently available is the 4.4-star Aplenty Chicken Pesto Thin and Crispy Pizza. As the name implies, it's topped with small chunks of white meat chicken along with a three-cheese blend of mozzarella, parmesan, and provolone. It's also the only non-red sauced pizza on our list, with basil-garlic pesto taking the place of the more-typical marinara. Despite being a little outside the pizza box, this product has plenty of devoted fans. "I'm not even that into pesto in general, but this pizza actually was very impressive. The flavor was so developed and top notch. I am definitely getting this again," vowed one. Someone else seconded, saying, "Was skeptical but it is absolutely delicious at a good price."

Purchase a 15.3-ounce Aplenty Chicken Pesto Thin and Crispy Pizza from Amazon.