10 Store-Bought Apple Pies, Ranked Worst To Hands-Down Best
As the weather cools and Thanksgiving gets closer, I find myself drawn more and more to the classically warm spices and flavors of cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg. Not only do these spices help to make the wonderfully bold and wholesome flavors of a nice cup of chai, but they're also common ingredients in more than one variety of common autumnal pie. While pumpkin pie may have come to mind, I'm much more enticed by a good slice of apple pie.
Maybe it's the New Englander blood, but visiting a local orchard and filling a basket with fresh apples before going home to bake a homemade pie is one of the best feelings, and flavors, in the world. However, not everyone has the chance to pick their own apples or the time needed to translate those apples into a perfectly crafted pie. So for those of us who need a speedier option, picking up a prepared pie from the grocery store is the best way to indulge that craving.
Where is the best place, though, to find an apple pie that satisfies? With the ability to ship pies to your door, every store offering prepared bakery pies, and even the presence of numerous frozen bake-at-home options, finding your way to the best can be tough. For that reason, The Takeout is here. Sit back while we look at 10 different pies from grocery stores and put them to the test before ranking them from worst to absolute best for your holiday purchasing needs.
10. Walmart's Marketside Apple Caramel Pie
Coming in last place is Walmart's Marketside caramel apple pie, which I picked up for $6.24. Visually, this pie was warm and inviting. The deep-amber colored drizzle of caramel pooled lightly in small puddles over the crumb topping. Richly browned tones on some of the larger crumbs promised a crisp texture and caramelized sugars to add the toasted notes that a good pastry develops as it browns.
My first impression of the flavors, and my last, was one of cloying sweetness. My tongue pulled back in shock as my teeth braced for the end of days. Despite the well-baked crumb, nothing could stand out against the sheer sugar content. All of my hopes were shattered in a single moment. While the visual appeal was undeniable, I couldn't even bring myself to finish the slice.
The apples, which were cut into small and thin bite-sized slices, were overly soft but did bring in at least some texture. Despite feeling them, the apples carried no flavor whatsoever. Even the flavor of cinnamon seemed more a memory than actual spice to be tasted. The crust barely held together, and the topping, which had a touch of crispness at the very top, was mostly just a sponge to soak up the pie's moisture. This made each bite an exercise in eating a pasty puddle of pure sweetness. Not all of these pies were a success, but this pie was undoubtedly the biggest let-down.
9. Walmart's Freshness Guaranteed Apple Pie
Taking its place second to last on our list is Walmart's second apple pie offering, this one from another of its private-label brands, Freshness Guaranteed. This 8-inch pie was the least expensive on the list, at just $4.94, and was a large step up from the Marketside pie. While far from perfect, this one was not so sweet that I couldn't manage to finish a slice.
The apples in the filling of this pie were cut into a mix of thin wedges and smaller pieces, and were surrounded by an ocean of that thick, silky, and spiced slurry-like gel apple pies are so well known for. The result of mixing cornstarch or flour into the filling before baking, the almost curd-like liquid works to both bind together the bits of apple and hold everything in place. Unfortunately, when relied upon too heavily, like in this pie, it can be used to replace some of the apple and leave the pie feeling empty. While the apples were baked well, more of the filling was syrupy apple slurry than it was actual apples.
Combined with a crust in desperate need of real butter, the Freshness Guaranteed pie uses shortening instead which provides less flavor, and the overly sweet pie just seemed to fall flat. While I appreciated the crust, the layers of it were too thick, and came across as a bit pasty after absorbing so much moisture from the filling.
8. Mrs. Smith's Frozen Dutch Apple Pie
Showing up for our eighth place spot is Mrs. Smith's Dutch apple pie, which I picked up from Stop & Shop for $5.99. One of the frozen pies I purchased, it was also the first to make it into my oven. This meant that all the other frozen pies were judged against it, and they won that contest one after the other.
The base crust was very light, flaky, and had a wonderful snap around the edges. It stayed dry on the bottom and didn't soak up too much filling. Because of this, the pie managed to keep its shape well. Unfortunately, that's where things started coming apart at the seams. The filling was too sweet despite just a touch of tartness, and the apples didn't quite manage to keep their texture. They were soft and mushy with only a hint of crunch and only at the thickest parts.
While there's little doubt that cinnamon made an appearance, it was so lightly used that it didn't bring the same warm and aromatic heartiness to the pie that I normally look for. The crumb topping was the worst part. Under the crunchy bits on top, the lower level of crumbs had absorbed so much moisture from the filling that it became a thick white paste that almost stuck together like unbaked bread dough. The flavor of this pie wasn't terrible, but the texture wasn't one I'd like to eat again.
7. Sara Lee Frozen Dutch Apple Pie
Managing to rise above Walmart's offerings, and making it to seventh place, is Sara Lee's frozen Dutch apple pie. I managed to pick this pie up at my local Stop & Shop for just $5.29. The instructions were very simple, and required little more than taking the pie out of the box and baking it for about an hour at 400 degrees Fahrenheit.
While it may have only managed to make it to seventh place on our list, this pie wasn't terrible by any means. Notably, the crumb topping was the best I tried among all five in that general style. Even after cooling, the crumb remained crunchy, sweet, and took on a warm nuttiness from being toasted. It paired well with the sweet and tart filling. The crust did have some flakiness to it, but it was lost texturally among the crispy bits of topping.
In the end, this pie's greatest sin was its lack of filling. The majority of the filling was thickened apple juice, and the pieces of apple that could be found were overcooked to the point of being mush. The company curated a nice overall flavor, but the skimping when it came to the filling really left me with the feeling that I wasn't getting enough bang for my buck.
6. Marie Callender's Frozen Dutch Apple Pie
Marie Callender's frozen Dutch apple pie, which I picked up at Walmart for $5.97, was one of the more interesting pies I tried. That isn't to say it was my favorite, but it also wasn't my least favorite. What made this pie so intriguing was that the crumb topping was left off of the pie so it could be added at the end of baking.
The topless pie was baked at 400 degrees Fahrenheit for about an hour, and then the instructions had me take the pie out of the oven and add the crumb topping. From there I was able to bake the topping to exactly the color I wanted, which took about 10 more minutes. The combination of an open top and separate crumb meant the inner filling managed to dry out enough to thicken, while the crumb topping didn't have to absorb the steam and stayed crunchy.
While this created a great texture for a pie, the topping was very sweet and so was the filling. Together, the two created a sugary slice of pie that almost made my teeth ache. Don't get me wrong, compared to our last place contender, this was a much better experience. Unfortunately, I just couldn't bring myself to enjoy more than a bit before needing a break. A bit of added lemon juice and a more consistent amount of apples may have solved the issue, but for now this pie didn't cut it.
5. Whole Foods Apple Pie
Making it to our fifth-place spot is this 9-inch apple pie offered by Whole Foods for $13.99. The look of the pie alone led me to expect that it would have made its way further along in our competition. Among all the pies I purchased for this piece, none had as strong a warm and homemade feel as this one did. The lumpy top and browned edges promised a pie stuffed full of apple goodness.
When baking anything with a fruit filling, or any other filling with a lot of moisture, the biggest challenge can be in avoiding a soggy bottom. There are many ways to avoid a soggy pie crust, but there are some mistakes that, once made, are difficult to deal with. In the case of this pie from Whole Foods, the largest problem was its water content. From the moment I cut into the pie, a thin layer of cinnamon-tinted liquid poured from the inside of the pie into the bottom of the dish, which quickly explained the mushy bottom crust I encountered while eating this slice of pie.
That being said, the apples were cooked perfectly and still had a bit of crunch and texture while also being soft and well-baked. The level of cinnamon was perfect. There was a warm spiced flavor that came through in each bite without overwhelming the fruit. The top crust and sides showed a flaky pastry that, surprisingly, used real butter. If not for the wet filling, this pie would have made it much higher up the list.
4. Target Favorite Day Lattice Top Apple Pie
Rounding out the bottom half of our list is this $5, 8-inch pie from Target. I love a lattice cut on top of my fruit pies. Not only do they create a beautiful image to look at, but they give the filling more open room to release its moisture and come together. In this case, I thought it was a nice twist that Target chose to dust the top of the pie in a light cinnamon sugar, which added just a bit of flavor and made the bits of crust on top a pleasure to eat on their own.
The thin wedge-shaped bits of apple were beautifully cooked, maintaining a fresh texture and chew while being softened enough to melt together with the crust as you eat. I found the sauce around them to have a light and sweet flavor, without tasting of pure sugar. The apples had a nice hint of tartness to them, which balanced well with the rest of the filling.
I will admit there was just a touch of sogginess to the bottom crust, but not so much as to feel like it had become claggy. The flakiness that the sides and top lattice had disappeared a bit in the bottom crust, enough so to notice but not enough to formally complain about. I'm not always a fan of Favorite Day's products, so it was nice to see them make a genuinely good pie.
3. Stop & Shop Traditional Apple Pie
This traditional double-crust apple pie was picked up at the Stop & Shop bakery for $6.99. Much like the Walmart and Whole Foods pies, it has a solid top crust rather than a crumb topping. I was surprised at how much I liked the crust despite the absence of butter being mentioned anywhere in the ingredients list.
While not quite as flaky or flavorful as the Whole Foods crust, there was a certain salty taste and crisp texture that made the edges delicious all on their own. The bottom crust also held together very well and didn't soak up the filling at all. Though it succeeded in remaining dry, and being prepared with a reasonable thickness, there was a lot of cracking as I cut a slice, and it was near impossible for the slice to hold itself together once removed from the tin. The crust was good, but the filling was the real standout here.
Not only were the apples cooked perfectly, but the cinnamon level was absolutely perfect. The apples were a bit mild in flavor, which made the fact that the cinnamon didn't completely overwhelm them a point of success. It's true this pie could have used a bit more acidity, but the level of sweetness was sufficiently low enough that the overall flavor felt balanced and not cloying. There were several areas where the pie could have been better, but this pie had a wonderful balance and flavor.
2. Marie Callender's Frozen Lattice Apple Pie
After recent disappointment with Marie Callender's lemon meringue pie, I was shocked to see such a drastic jump in quality and flavor. Where the lemon had tasted fake and processed, this apple pie ($6.27 from Walmart) was quite good. True, the crust had a more crumbly texture that clearly came from using a fat other than real butter, but this frozen pie surprised me with its flavor.
The apples in this pie were mostly diced, with an occasional larger chunk to be found. This allowed the pie to feel full of apples, while also creating a more homogenous blend of fruit pieces and gooey apple slurry. The first bite of this pie hit me with a sharp tang that lit up my mouth and made the sweetness of the fruit and savory hint of cinnamon really stand out. This left the top crust and filling desperate to spread out over the plate as it left the back crust behind. However, even the wet filling couldn't undo the crispy bottom of the pie crust which managed to hold its texture perfectly even as it soaked up the moisture in the filling.
I was quite pleased to find that the filling had a very bright apple flavor, and reminded me of a nice glass of apple cider, though perhaps with a bit less spice. Despite not having a mountain of apples, every bite had enough apple to leave me feeling as though the pie had been filled well.
1. Trader Joe's Apple Crumble Pie
Taking the crown as our number one store-bought pie is the apple crumble pie from Trader Joe's. At the surprisingly low cost of $7.99, this was the most apple-packed pie of all the contenders. If someone showed up at my home with this pie, I'd have trouble believing it wasn't homemade.
Even cutting into this pie I noticed just how packed full of apples it was. The thin slices of apples were stacked so densely that I could feel the knife slice through each layer. I was so shocked that I started picking up other pies to compare their weight to this fruit-packed behemoth. From the first bite I was hit with a tsunami of tart and fresh apple flavor. Each piece of apple snapped a bit as it gave way and left me feeling as if I was eating them freshly picked off the tree. I'll admit, I prefer my pie apples cooked a bit more, such as in Trader Joe's mini pies, but I couldn't argue with the flavor.
The crumb topping had a rich nutty flavor, likely from the oats, and a delightful crunch and sweetness that married perfectly with the tart apples. For once the Dutch-style topping wasn't putting sugar on top of sugar, but rather acting as a sweet balance to the well-spiced sour apple flavor. Combining the two with a bit of the salty butter-filled crust made for a perfect bite. It's not often I buy a dessert instead of bringing my own, but the next time I do it will be this pie.
Methodology
When working on a piece like this, it is important to find as much of a variety as possible in both style and branding. In my experience, apple pie has two main styles. The first is usually referred to as Dutch apple pie or apple crumble pie and is topped with a sweet and buttery crumb sprinkle. The second style is the more traditional double crust pie, which has a second layer of crust on top, either covering the whole pie or cut into a lattice of some variety.
In searching everyday grocers for pies, I found that both styles of pie were about equally common. Without even trying, a combination of five pies in each of the two categories fell into my lap. Almost as serendipitously, because I wanted to find a combination of pre-baked and bake-at-home pies, our final selection contained four frozen pies to be baked before serving, and six bakery pies from nationally-known grocers.
Once the pies had been selected, it was simply a matter of baking or heating each pie and tasting them. I judged each by its crust, level of sweetness, amount and quality of apples, overall taste, and texture. I granted loosely-based point totals to each of those categories as a numerical baseline, which was then judged against the overall satisfaction each pie brought to the table. After all, sometimes objective perfection doesn't equal the best option.