Costco's Latest Bakery Find Is Made For Peanut Butter And Chocolate Lovers

Costco's bakery is the gift that keeps on giving this year. In the days since Costco's 2025 holiday cookie tray reappeared, consumers have discovered yet another delicious addition to the store's bakery lineup. This time, it comes in the form of a peanut butter chocolate fudge platter which has arrived just this month and has already impressed and delighted a handful of Costco shoppers. The trays were first reported on December 2. They feature eight pieces of fudge and weigh roughly 25 ounces in total. Each of these evenly-sliced pieces is made up of a top layer of creamy peanut butter fudge, a thick bottom layer of chocolate fudge, and some chocolate drizzle across the top to really strengthen the popular flavor combo.

While the aforementioned contents of the tray make it a great option for satisfying your sweet tooth next time you visit Costco, it gets even better when looking at the price. At just $14.99, the roughly 3-ounce pieces of fudge cost less than $2 each and around $9.59 per pound, a price point that's relatively affordable for store-bought fudge which makes the new item even more desirable.

While Costco is far from the first store chain to offer delicious fudge in its bakery (it's made fresh each and every day at Buc-ee's, for example), the new release is already getting plenty of praise from those who have been able to find it in the 6 days since it was first discovered. Many people are impressed with the quality of the fudge in relation to its price, with many noting that its taste is indulgent and difficult to put down. Among the most common points of praise the treat has received is its texture. While some have said Costco's product can be a bit too firm to the bite for their liking, its notable creaminess is what prevails above all else for most consumers. Considering how creaminess is a trait that separate mediocre fudge from great fudge for many enthusiasts, the new Costco item finds itself in good company.

Unsurprisingly, the biggest fans of the new fudge bars are those who absolutely adore the peanut butter and chocolate combo. While making peanut butter fudge at home is fairly simple, it can prove to be difficult to get the perfect balance of chocolate and peanut butter, especially for those who've never successfully made fudge in the past. Costco's newest product is great for those wanting to satiate their peanut butter and chocolate craving without needing to get their hands dirty.